Solid State or Tube preamp?
+13
wabun
Landy
arremie
dixchen
noodle88
sswong3374
rsbn589
azri
123_rocketman
bassraptor
cmboy
tlkoo
teleman51
17 posters
Hi-Fi 4 Sale - Malaysia / Singapore Audio Forum & Marketplace | www.hifi4sale.net :: Discussion Forum & Knowledge Base :: Equipment Discussions
Page 1 of 2
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Solid State or Tube preamp?
To all the sifus & hifi bro ,
Just wanted to get a general opinion from all as to whether a s/state or tube preamp is better.
You see my problem is that I have a vintage leak stereo 20 power amp (in working condition.)and have been looking around for the matching preamp, but when I heard it , found it to be noisy.
I have been looking to pair it with a proper preamp for a while now.
Now I'm using all s/state gear but would love to get that Leak going though
Since I love vintage tube gear, obviously it would be natural to lean towards a tube preamp but have been told that a good s/state would serve better, not to mention cost much less to buy and maintain as well.
Any opinions on this.
Cheers & Shalom
teleman51
Just wanted to get a general opinion from all as to whether a s/state or tube preamp is better.
You see my problem is that I have a vintage leak stereo 20 power amp (in working condition.)and have been looking around for the matching preamp, but when I heard it , found it to be noisy.
I have been looking to pair it with a proper preamp for a while now.
Now I'm using all s/state gear but would love to get that Leak going though
Since I love vintage tube gear, obviously it would be natural to lean towards a tube preamp but have been told that a good s/state would serve better, not to mention cost much less to buy and maintain as well.
Any opinions on this.
Cheers & Shalom
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
i reckon it depends on what you expect your preamp to do
in my case, i just want my preamp to manage signal drive thus i have found a preamp which sounds neutral any coloration i desire either takes place at source stage or power amplification stage... and so happened that my preamp is a solid state chip-based one
whilst i must say that some guys want their preamps to be like artists in coloring the sound etc etc... long stories...
so... teleman51, what you want your potential preamp to do?
regards
audiobro
in my case, i just want my preamp to manage signal drive thus i have found a preamp which sounds neutral any coloration i desire either takes place at source stage or power amplification stage... and so happened that my preamp is a solid state chip-based one
whilst i must say that some guys want their preamps to be like artists in coloring the sound etc etc... long stories...
so... teleman51, what you want your potential preamp to do?
regards
audiobro
teleman51 wrote:To all the sifus & hifi bro ,
Just wanted to get a general opinion from all as to whether a s/state or tube preamp is better.
You see my problem is that I have a vintage leak stereo 20 power amp (in working condition.)and have been looking around for the matching preamp, but when I heard it , found it to be noisy.
I have been looking to pair it with a proper preamp for a while now.
Now I'm using all s/state gear but would love to get that Leak going though
Since I love vintage tube gear, obviously it would be natural to lean towards a tube preamp but have been told that a good s/state would serve better, not to mention cost much less to buy and maintain as well.
Any opinions on this.
Cheers & Shalom
teleman51
Last edited by tlkoo on Tue Mar 09, 2010 6:51 am; edited 1 time in total
tlkoo- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 346
Age : 53
Location : kuala lumpur
Registration date : 2009-05-04
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Thanks for the reply tlkoo,
I really would like the preamp to be able to come out with some clean & clear sound for a start.
Sadder still I'm still addicted to tone controls so you can call me old school.Others have tried to wean me off but to no avail
Someone said that I could not live with the new types of amps with only 2 or 3 knobs.They were right though.
I got quite a fright when I bought my Pioneer A400 from a fellow forumer, and found to my horror only 3 knobs
I have lived my life happily with a Marantz receiver bought in 1977,used it till about 2005 and it was bliss until I sent it for servicing and the repairman closed shop & took off with my Marantz.Those were the days of the "colored" sound, I suppose.
Am I wishing for that kind of sound again.I think so.
Maybe our brother forumer hoyhoysum would be my kind of guy.
Cheers & shalom
teleman51
I really would like the preamp to be able to come out with some clean & clear sound for a start.
Sadder still I'm still addicted to tone controls so you can call me old school.Others have tried to wean me off but to no avail
Someone said that I could not live with the new types of amps with only 2 or 3 knobs.They were right though.
I got quite a fright when I bought my Pioneer A400 from a fellow forumer, and found to my horror only 3 knobs
I have lived my life happily with a Marantz receiver bought in 1977,used it till about 2005 and it was bliss until I sent it for servicing and the repairman closed shop & took off with my Marantz.Those were the days of the "colored" sound, I suppose.
Am I wishing for that kind of sound again.I think so.
Maybe our brother forumer hoyhoysum would be my kind of guy.
Cheers & shalom
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Leak ST20 have sufficient sensitivity to match a 100k impedance passive preamp and the sonics will depend purely on the merit of the Leak amp, no more color, distortion or extra dynamic juices added. A DIY with ALPS Blue 100k volume pot (of course you can choose other boutique brands) passive pre will do just fine and doesn't cost very much.
cmboy- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1298
Age : 44
Location : The Eagle's Nest
Registration date : 2009-03-11
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
bassraptor wrote:Is it advisable to pair a solid-state preamp with a tube power amp?
If you happen to have a vintage amp like Quad II, its highly suggested to match a pre-amp to it. Those Quad just don't have sufficient sensitivity by design. Its entirely a power amplifier by all intent. You'd be turning up the volume to 3 o'clock to get a listenable volume if its matched or fitted with a passive preamp.
OTH, a high quality, transparent, uncolored, lowest noise possible SS preamp can do justice to a tube amp. However its up to the owner's satisfaction on choice and the end result.
cmboy- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1298
Age : 44
Location : The Eagle's Nest
Registration date : 2009-03-11
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Thanks cmboy & bassraptor,
I'm seriously taking all views into consideration but must admit here that most importantly the preamp must have good number of tone controls, loudness switch and all thats' unfashionable now.
Maybe I come across sounding anti establishment, but what the heck, it's all about the music anyway.
Now I'm off to play some CCR & gold old 70's music
cheers & shalom
teleman51
I'm seriously taking all views into consideration but must admit here that most importantly the preamp must have good number of tone controls, loudness switch and all thats' unfashionable now.
Maybe I come across sounding anti establishment, but what the heck, it's all about the music anyway.
Now I'm off to play some CCR & gold old 70's music
cheers & shalom
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Perhaps you'd consider this option. Passive pre + graphic equalizer.
Reminds me I still have my 20 year old Technics 12 band graphic equalizer. Time for me to do something with it. Yes, I do like tone controls too.
Audiolab 8000C would be a decent and affordable match, lots of input, outputs, tape outs, can connect to subwoofer, slim and not very bulky like ARC, lots of knobs, think got bass treble knobs, quite neutral sound.. how leh?
Reminds me I still have my 20 year old Technics 12 band graphic equalizer. Time for me to do something with it. Yes, I do like tone controls too.
Audiolab 8000C would be a decent and affordable match, lots of input, outputs, tape outs, can connect to subwoofer, slim and not very bulky like ARC, lots of knobs, think got bass treble knobs, quite neutral sound.. how leh?
cmboy- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1298
Age : 44
Location : The Eagle's Nest
Registration date : 2009-03-11
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
You can try Eico HF 85 pre. It has knobs to control volume, bass and treble. The icing on the cake is you can control them separately, which means you can have one side sound louder with higher treble and the other with lower bass or whichever combinations you desire!! This will definitely satisfy your "lust" to the max.
123_rocketman- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 189
Age : 66
Location : Shah Alam
Registration date : 2009-03-07
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Oh, by the way, it is a tube pre.
123_rocketman- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 189
Age : 66
Location : Shah Alam
Registration date : 2009-03-07
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
one thing about valve is, it looks hideous but it sounded as sweet as can be..
azri- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1050
Age : 47
Location : bangi, selangor
Registration date : 2009-01-21
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
you will hate yourself coz you can no longer play around with tone controls, at the same time you keep smiling as you cant believe the sound valve produces throughout your listening session everytime you turn on your music!!
azri- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1050
Age : 47
Location : bangi, selangor
Registration date : 2009-01-21
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
go for valve pre + ss power amp, but bare in mind you may need a high output power amp, at least 100w/ch or you can experience lack of dynamics. im running on 180w/ch, next step expected to be 220w/ch rotel or settle down with krell big bad ass later on
azri- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1050
Age : 47
Location : bangi, selangor
Registration date : 2009-01-21
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
teleman51,
May I know what speakers you are using? Leak tube amps are with high input sensitity (~0.125mV) which is too high for active pre-amp. You may try passive pre but as you like to play with knobs, I would suggest vintage pre. EICO HF85 is good but you may explore others like Fisher, Scott, Mcintosh pres etc. And it is advisble to install shunt resistors in your Leak ST20 to match with active pres.
Regards.
May I know what speakers you are using? Leak tube amps are with high input sensitity (~0.125mV) which is too high for active pre-amp. You may try passive pre but as you like to play with knobs, I would suggest vintage pre. EICO HF85 is good but you may explore others like Fisher, Scott, Mcintosh pres etc. And it is advisble to install shunt resistors in your Leak ST20 to match with active pres.
Regards.
rsbn589- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 246
Age : 56
Location : Seremban
Registration date : 2009-03-02
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
bassraptor wrote:Is it advisable to pair a solid-state preamp with a tube power amp?
Some people prefer using ss pre + tube pwr than tube pre + ss power combination. As they said got better control and dynamic...
sswong3374- Club Member
- Number of posts : 33
Age : 50
Location : PJ
Registration date : 2009-03-12
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
sswong3374 wrote:bassraptor wrote:Is it advisable to pair a solid-state preamp with a tube power amp?
Some people prefer using ss pre + tube pwr than tube pre + ss power combination. As they said got better control and dynamic...
I would say full tube system sing better, from tube dac output to tube poweramp. Perferable with interstage tranfomer all the way n no cap in the signal path , is the best of the best....
Cheers,
noodle88- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 430
Age : 51
Location : Shah Alam
Registration date : 2009-03-13
Character sheet
Source(s): Turntable
Amplification: Tube gear
Speakers: High sensitivity speaker
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
sswong3374 wrote:bassraptor wrote:Is it advisable to pair a solid-state preamp with a tube power amp?
Some people prefer using ss pre + tube pwr than tube pre + ss power combination. As they said got better control and dynamic...
it depends on the sonic characters of each equipment, though not much use to decide based on specifications, or commonly known sonic characters thereof et al as eventually the state-of-the-art measuring devices (our ears lah!) are to acknowledge delivery huh i don't trust that all must be tubes neither all must be solid state, nor hybrid... our ears to judge lah...
tlkoo- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 346
Age : 53
Location : kuala lumpur
Registration date : 2009-05-04
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
sswong3374 wrote:bassraptor wrote:Is it advisable to pair a solid-state preamp with a tube power amp?
Some people prefer using ss pre + tube pwr than tube pre + ss power combination. As they said got better control and dynamic...
That's an odd combination, any pre amp voices a great percentage of the sound of any system. SS over tube, defeats the purpose of a tube amp really then...thus why manufacturers come out with hybrid amps...all tube on the pre side of things..
Like noodle88 has mentioned, tube DAC output to tube pre to trans in between be it interstage trans or not, ( really nothing wrong with coupling caps too actually, the phase shifts with cc's are not audible half the time provided they are of an extremely high quality) then finally to a tube amp ( SET preferrably
Either all ss or tube pre to add a tube flavour to the SS equipment.
But these are my own views...not all will agree with this..
dixchen- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 255
Age : 48
Location : Subang Jaya
Registration date : 2009-02-17
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
rsbn,
i'm using a pair of slightly modified Rogers LS4/2a.Decent enough speakers although a touch too laid back.They're British, so you can expect that of the Brits.
Fisher, Scott & Macintosh are hardly available here at decent prices, not to mention the EICO.
Zenn in S'pore has a Nelson Audio image 2000 up for sale S$550.What do you think?
To all brothers who've contributed to the thread, my heartfelt gratitude for your sharing of thoughts and knowledge.Your'e all a terrific bunch of guys.
noodle88, you're the man.
cmboy, will also check out the audiolab 8000c.
thanks all
regards & shalom
teleman51
i'm using a pair of slightly modified Rogers LS4/2a.Decent enough speakers although a touch too laid back.They're British, so you can expect that of the Brits.
Fisher, Scott & Macintosh are hardly available here at decent prices, not to mention the EICO.
Zenn in S'pore has a Nelson Audio image 2000 up for sale S$550.What do you think?
To all brothers who've contributed to the thread, my heartfelt gratitude for your sharing of thoughts and knowledge.Your'e all a terrific bunch of guys.
noodle88, you're the man.
cmboy, will also check out the audiolab 8000c.
thanks all
regards & shalom
teleman51
Last edited by teleman51 on Tue Mar 09, 2010 7:14 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : grammatical errors)
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
have to agree with dixchen. i always was led to believe that you can pair a tube pre with a s/s power, but not advisable to use s/s pre with tube power .. in any case, it's not a combination i've tried, although i've used passive s/s pre with tube power amp with good results (but this is another territory). certainly not active s/s preamp with tube power.
in fact, i can't think of any hybrid integrated that uses s/s pre stage and tube power stage, it's the other way around ...
... feel free to correct me ...
in fact, i can't think of any hybrid integrated that uses s/s pre stage and tube power stage, it's the other way around ...
... feel free to correct me ...
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
bassraptor,
your post makes sense, and most all of the stuff out there bears you
out.
Errr, but I don't understand whether a passive can be considered s/state per se.
A passive as I understand it is neither here nor there.It's just well, uhhh
passive! Forgive me if I'm mistaken
I'm just a new kid on the block.Or old timer who does'nt know better, to phrase it better.
Errrrr, know anyone whos' giving up an EICO HF85 for adoption.
Looking to give a loving home & willing to pay a decent price if I could find a good condition unit .Highly recommended by Bro rsbn5869.
cheers & shalom
teleman51
your post makes sense, and most all of the stuff out there bears you
out.
Errr, but I don't understand whether a passive can be considered s/state per se.
A passive as I understand it is neither here nor there.It's just well, uhhh
passive! Forgive me if I'm mistaken
I'm just a new kid on the block.Or old timer who does'nt know better, to phrase it better.
Errrrr, know anyone whos' giving up an EICO HF85 for adoption.
Looking to give a loving home & willing to pay a decent price if I could find a good condition unit .Highly recommended by Bro rsbn5869.
cheers & shalom
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
ha ha ... you're right, teleman (you're a guitarist?) ... passive, i suppose, is neither ... since there's no glass, i referred to it as solid-state, but it's just transformers, i guess!
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
i am not claiming that it is good sounding though it is a commercial product i.e. amc 3030 integrated model is a hybrid of solid state preamp with tube power amp!
though they are not commercial products, my pre is solid state and power is tube! what is wrong? though i could not claim tube pre fairs better, my combo sounds good enough as it is (i mean in absolute sense without any comparison)
in any case, my philosophy in audio is simple i.e. comparisons never end, treasure the absolute!!! that said, my philosophy is not absolute either ha...
cheers
though they are not commercial products, my pre is solid state and power is tube! what is wrong? though i could not claim tube pre fairs better, my combo sounds good enough as it is (i mean in absolute sense without any comparison)
in any case, my philosophy in audio is simple i.e. comparisons never end, treasure the absolute!!! that said, my philosophy is not absolute either ha...
cheers
bassraptor wrote:have to agree with dixchen. i always was led to believe that you can pair a tube pre with a s/s power, but not advisable to use s/s pre with tube power .. in any case, it's not a combination i've tried, although i've used passive s/s pre with tube power amp with good results (but this is another territory). certainly not active s/s preamp with tube power.
in fact, i can't think of any hybrid integrated that uses s/s pre stage and tube power stage, it's the other way around ...
... feel free to correct me ...
Last edited by tlkoo on Wed Mar 10, 2010 8:05 am; edited 3 times in total
tlkoo- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 346
Age : 53
Location : kuala lumpur
Registration date : 2009-05-04
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
teleman51,
I have not auditioned Nelson Audio hence no comment. I have owned and listened to Rogers speakers so I guess I understand your meaning of laid back. IMO, EICO HF85 is the best buy vintage pre which offers good sound for both linestage and phonostage. Thick vocal and body, musical and one may find it too color and not as quieter background as other pres like the Fisher, Marantz etc. Nonetheless, to partner with vintage tube amps for example Leak ST20, I would prefer pres like Fisher 50C, 400CX, 400CX2 or Scott 122. They are not common in this region but quite popular for vintage fans, me included!
Regards.
I have not auditioned Nelson Audio hence no comment. I have owned and listened to Rogers speakers so I guess I understand your meaning of laid back. IMO, EICO HF85 is the best buy vintage pre which offers good sound for both linestage and phonostage. Thick vocal and body, musical and one may find it too color and not as quieter background as other pres like the Fisher, Marantz etc. Nonetheless, to partner with vintage tube amps for example Leak ST20, I would prefer pres like Fisher 50C, 400CX, 400CX2 or Scott 122. They are not common in this region but quite popular for vintage fans, me included!
Regards.
rsbn589- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 246
Age : 56
Location : Seremban
Registration date : 2009-03-02
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Yes bassraptor,
I'm a little bit of an aspiring guitar (own 5) player as my avatar suggests and what I know of tube amps happen to be tube guitar amps mostly.All mono, no stereo haha!
Topology wise, I suppose they are all aboutl the same,except that for hifi it's basically x2.
I'm a die hard tube fan I guess, but I've got nothing against s/state gear although I would'nt buy a solid state guitar amp in a million years.
rsbn589,
thanks for the tips, but now see what you've gone and done.
I'm already thinking of where I'm going to find one of those you mentioned.Heard the Leak Point One Stereo at a friends place a few weeks back and found it wonderfully colored with tone knobs to play with, but alas it was awfully noisy as well.
Time to pray to the good Lord to make my dream come true.
cheers & shalom to all
teleman51
I'm a little bit of an aspiring guitar (own 5) player as my avatar suggests and what I know of tube amps happen to be tube guitar amps mostly.All mono, no stereo haha!
Topology wise, I suppose they are all aboutl the same,except that for hifi it's basically x2.
I'm a die hard tube fan I guess, but I've got nothing against s/state gear although I would'nt buy a solid state guitar amp in a million years.
rsbn589,
thanks for the tips, but now see what you've gone and done.
I'm already thinking of where I'm going to find one of those you mentioned.Heard the Leak Point One Stereo at a friends place a few weeks back and found it wonderfully colored with tone knobs to play with, but alas it was awfully noisy as well.
Time to pray to the good Lord to make my dream come true.
cheers & shalom to all
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
tlkoo, ah yes, the AMC 3030, a pretty decent little amp, i remember it now ... a bit ahead of its time, pity the company didn't last to see the tube revival! I had one for a while. A rare one indeed.
Teleman: I'm with you on the guitar gear! My last and best guitar amp was a refurbished Twin Reverb! My bass amp is an all-tube Ampeg. I keep a Mesa Baron hi-fi power amp on standby for the times I'm bored ...
Teleman: I'm with you on the guitar gear! My last and best guitar amp was a refurbished Twin Reverb! My bass amp is an all-tube Ampeg. I keep a Mesa Baron hi-fi power amp on standby for the times I'm bored ...
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
bassraptor,
glad to hear that you're a tube guitar amp fan too.
However, I don't understand what you mean by last and best.You mean you don't have one anymore.
Have several of these amps, so please pm me .You can drop by to play with my toys like a blackface Showman,Bandmaster and even a '75 Twin Reverb, refurbished to blackface.Would love to meet up with a fellow musician
Can't really say that the twin is the best but to each his own.
Me, I really love the tones of the lower powered amps and am having a customised 18 watt baby Marshall being made for me.
For bass players, I'll agree that the Ampeg is the way to go though.
cheers & shalom
teleman51
glad to hear that you're a tube guitar amp fan too.
However, I don't understand what you mean by last and best.You mean you don't have one anymore.
Have several of these amps, so please pm me .You can drop by to play with my toys like a blackface Showman,Bandmaster and even a '75 Twin Reverb, refurbished to blackface.Would love to meet up with a fellow musician
Can't really say that the twin is the best but to each his own.
Me, I really love the tones of the lower powered amps and am having a customised 18 watt baby Marshall being made for me.
For bass players, I'll agree that the Ampeg is the way to go though.
cheers & shalom
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
actually, i'm not much of an electric guitar player, the twin was an indulgence. i've gone thru a few amps over the past 20 years, but as far as clean tone from a tube amp is concerned, those old twin reverbs are the thing. yes, i agree, other tube amps do other things better, and i especially like the overdrive on such amps. my twin was a late-60s refurbished to blackface specs. anyway, sold it already.
you been in touch with ceriatone?
as for ampegs, mine's the last of the US made ones. for pure and dirty and loud rock tone, though, the all-tube marshall stack stokes my fire ...
sorry to digress, guys ....
you been in touch with ceriatone?
as for ampegs, mine's the last of the US made ones. for pure and dirty and loud rock tone, though, the all-tube marshall stack stokes my fire ...
sorry to digress, guys ....
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
dixchen,
I also agree that ss pre + tube power is odd/non conventional combination. Anyway never try never know. So far my friend from HK is happy with such combination (colne passlab pre + 300B), my other friend try to use audiolab to drive the 300B but he don't like the sound.
so it's really depend on individual's need and taste.
Basically those who use tube pre or tube buffer + ss pwr are people who wish to have large power to drive the speaker (more choice on speaker) but can still have some tube feeling.
then those who really like the tube feel will prefer full tube combination with suitable speaker (less choice)
then come another group of people (mostly those use 300B) who initially using full tube system to high sensitivity speaker and found their amp is not dynamic enough, some may try to use interstage then small group may try other alternative like using ss pre.
I'm a tube lover but i had to admit that it is easier to get ss preamp with good dynamic with control than a tube preamp.
I also agree that ss pre + tube power is odd/non conventional combination. Anyway never try never know. So far my friend from HK is happy with such combination (colne passlab pre + 300B), my other friend try to use audiolab to drive the 300B but he don't like the sound.
so it's really depend on individual's need and taste.
Basically those who use tube pre or tube buffer + ss pwr are people who wish to have large power to drive the speaker (more choice on speaker) but can still have some tube feeling.
then those who really like the tube feel will prefer full tube combination with suitable speaker (less choice)
then come another group of people (mostly those use 300B) who initially using full tube system to high sensitivity speaker and found their amp is not dynamic enough, some may try to use interstage then small group may try other alternative like using ss pre.
I'm a tube lover but i had to admit that it is easier to get ss preamp with good dynamic with control than a tube preamp.
sswong3374- Club Member
- Number of posts : 33
Age : 50
Location : PJ
Registration date : 2009-03-12
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
sswong3374 wrote:I also agree that ss pre + tube power is odd/non conventional combination. Anyway never try never know. So far my friend from HK is happy with such combination (colne passlab pre + 300B), my other friend try to use audiolab to drive the 300B but he don't like the sound.
so it's really depend on individual's need and taste.
Basically those who use tube pre or tube buffer + ss pwr are people who wish to have large power to drive the speaker (more choice on speaker) but can still have some tube feeling.
Excellent point as to individual need and taste. Large power to drive speaker?.. well that can only be true or usable to a certain degree and depends on the volume range one will put up during listening. We're speaking about this Leak Stereo 20 which averages about 12Watt at full peak power. Whatever preamp you match will not increase the music power but may start coloring, produce unnatural tones and may even occur distortion at peak power demands or at some heavy low level passages. You're not going to get fuller and tighter bass lines with some preamp thats reputed to be powerful, dynamic and rich sounding (or whatever the claims and reputation it may have). Vintage Leak pre-amps happen to be noisy buggers, due to its design of the day.
cmboy- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1298
Age : 44
Location : The Eagle's Nest
Registration date : 2009-03-11
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
sswong3374 wrote:dixchen,
then come another group of people (mostly those use 300B) who initially using full tube system to high sensitivity speaker and found their amp is not dynamic enough, some may try to use interstage then small group may try other alternative like using ss pre.
I'm a tube lover but i had to admit that it is easier to get ss preamp with good dynamic with control than a tube preamp.
Sswong3374,
I don't agree what u mention about tube pre don't have enough dynamic. Tube pre can be hyper dynamic ie. The Vacumm State Eletronics fvp2 it's give u all that u want. Being a 300b amp not dynamic enough is nothing wrong with the preamp, is the amp's fault.
noodle88- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 430
Age : 51
Location : Shah Alam
Registration date : 2009-03-13
Character sheet
Source(s): Turntable
Amplification: Tube gear
Speakers: High sensitivity speaker
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
http://www.soundstage.com/noisy04.htm
arremie- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 533
Location : PJ
Registration date : 2009-02-09
Character sheet
Source(s): Oppo
Amplification: Parasound
Speakers: Klipsch
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Noodles88,
i think u misunderstand what i mean "EASIER to get a ss preamp than tube pre amp with good dynamic" ..it doesn't mean tube pre can't be dynamic.
By the way what is the cost of a Vacumm State Eletronics fvp2?
i think u misunderstand what i mean "EASIER to get a ss preamp than tube pre amp with good dynamic" ..it doesn't mean tube pre can't be dynamic.
By the way what is the cost of a Vacumm State Eletronics fvp2?
sswong3374- Club Member
- Number of posts : 33
Age : 50
Location : PJ
Registration date : 2009-03-12
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
I can assure u all, ones u click on a tube preamp u will not going back to Ss pre....
If I'm not wrong the vse svp2 is priced around rm 30k.
If I'm not wrong the vse svp2 is priced around rm 30k.
noodle88- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 430
Age : 51
Location : Shah Alam
Registration date : 2009-03-13
Character sheet
Source(s): Turntable
Amplification: Tube gear
Speakers: High sensitivity speaker
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
noodle88,
yeah, I feel like I'm leaning towards a tube pre amp anyway.
The old Leak Stereo has been lying around for a while now, and
I've only just worked up an itch to start getting her going.
Will now have to keep my ears & eyes wide open for a good condition
tube pre.
May just hop over down to Singapore to see if there's any good used unit over there.
Now that I've just turned 55, gotta be careful with my spending.
Then there's the wife acceptance factor to consider.
Yes cmboy,
vintage Leak pre amps are really noisy buggers.Looks like I'll have to use the RCA commectors on the Stereo 20 chassis instead of the 8 pin umbilical cord which originally comes with the unit.Then have to modify to add on/off switch as the power unit does not have it's own but rather is switched on by the matching pre.
bassraptor, you've got a pm from me.
Thanks all.
cheers & shalom
teleman51
yeah, I feel like I'm leaning towards a tube pre amp anyway.
The old Leak Stereo has been lying around for a while now, and
I've only just worked up an itch to start getting her going.
Will now have to keep my ears & eyes wide open for a good condition
tube pre.
May just hop over down to Singapore to see if there's any good used unit over there.
Now that I've just turned 55, gotta be careful with my spending.
Then there's the wife acceptance factor to consider.
Yes cmboy,
vintage Leak pre amps are really noisy buggers.Looks like I'll have to use the RCA commectors on the Stereo 20 chassis instead of the 8 pin umbilical cord which originally comes with the unit.Then have to modify to add on/off switch as the power unit does not have it's own but rather is switched on by the matching pre.
bassraptor, you've got a pm from me.
Thanks all.
cheers & shalom
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
I do have the Point One stereo preamp which I picked up from Down under years ago. Somewhat a bit less than ideal condition and now remains nothing more than a collectible. Last I listened to it, really needs a workover.
cmboy- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1298
Age : 44
Location : The Eagle's Nest
Registration date : 2009-03-11
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
cmboy, I remember that you said you have Leak 12.1 but put under bed. What happened then? Mind to tell?
rsbn589- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 246
Age : 56
Location : Seremban
Registration date : 2009-03-02
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
cmboy,
you picked it up from down under your bed or Ozzieland.
Is it still in a somewhat working condition or what.
After the workover, would it be less noisy or what?
Or is it it's inherent character.
Any possibility of ugrading it to modern specs.
May interest me if the unit's future prospects are good.
Please let me know.
Cheers & shalom
teleman51
you picked it up from down under your bed or Ozzieland.
Is it still in a somewhat working condition or what.
After the workover, would it be less noisy or what?
Or is it it's inherent character.
Any possibility of ugrading it to modern specs.
May interest me if the unit's future prospects are good.
Please let me know.
Cheers & shalom
teleman51
Last edited by teleman51 on Wed Mar 10, 2010 10:19 pm; edited 1 time in total (Reason for editing : addition of smiley)
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Hey guys, lets not shift the focus on me or whats under my bed, closet, bathroom or the cellar.
Mr Teleman51 here needs some answers, not me.
Mr Teleman51 here needs some answers, not me.
cmboy- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1298
Age : 44
Location : The Eagle's Nest
Registration date : 2009-03-11
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
mr teleman51
maka kecek sokmo tak kan tahu
lagi baik coba sokmo ni tu
wasalam
kooman
maka kecek sokmo tak kan tahu
lagi baik coba sokmo ni tu
wasalam
kooman
tlkoo- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 346
Age : 53
Location : kuala lumpur
Registration date : 2009-05-04
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Does an opinion from a girl matter???
Anyway, here goes. Yes, valves, nice but never enough driving power. A live musical performance has a kind of tension, a kind of rawness and edginess that valves just smoothens out too much. To get close to real musical reproduction you need power, speed and accuracy of tone. Valves are too coloured.
You can get closer to a live performance with SS than vith Valves with the same amount of money spent. Of course if you spend even more money on the valves then I don't deny valves can come close to the real thing.
But having said that, a good valve pre driving a SS power amp can be quite an interesting prospect.
Anyway, here goes. Yes, valves, nice but never enough driving power. A live musical performance has a kind of tension, a kind of rawness and edginess that valves just smoothens out too much. To get close to real musical reproduction you need power, speed and accuracy of tone. Valves are too coloured.
You can get closer to a live performance with SS than vith Valves with the same amount of money spent. Of course if you spend even more money on the valves then I don't deny valves can come close to the real thing.
But having said that, a good valve pre driving a SS power amp can be quite an interesting prospect.
Landy- Regular
- Number of posts : 60
Age : 47
Location : Penang
Registration date : 2010-03-09
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
tlkoo,
you say what ah?
pohm mai kowchai, karp.
Landy, what you say is credible but valves do have a solid following.
At my age I've seen the slow fading away of valves and the rise of solid state starting in the 60's.
Come the 90's valves start becoming the rave again And s/state have taken the market, with excellent gear coming out.
Both have their strong & weak points.
Me, my ears want to hear the sounds of the 70's but have to face the reality of the new millenium with really modern gear, giving out the 'new' sound.
Even talking about cables can run into pages and pages.
There was a time I was running an 8 track cassette through a Marantz receiver with Wharfedale speakers and honestly believed I was in hifi heaven.
Time marches on sadly.sigh!
cheers & shalom.
teleman51
you say what ah?
pohm mai kowchai, karp.
Landy, what you say is credible but valves do have a solid following.
At my age I've seen the slow fading away of valves and the rise of solid state starting in the 60's.
Come the 90's valves start becoming the rave again And s/state have taken the market, with excellent gear coming out.
Both have their strong & weak points.
Me, my ears want to hear the sounds of the 70's but have to face the reality of the new millenium with really modern gear, giving out the 'new' sound.
Even talking about cables can run into pages and pages.
There was a time I was running an 8 track cassette through a Marantz receiver with Wharfedale speakers and honestly believed I was in hifi heaven.
Time marches on sadly.sigh!
cheers & shalom.
teleman51
teleman51- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 147
Age : 69
Location : Gombak
Registration date : 2009-01-20
Character sheet
Source(s): Marantz CD52 MK2.Ipod 4
Amplification: Marantz 2265 Receiver,Marantz 3800 Preamp,Marantz 140 Power amp,Marantz 1060 integrated
Speakers: Acoustic Energy Evo 1
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Does an opinion from a girl matter???
Anyway, here goes. Yes, valves, nice but never enough driving power. A live musical performance has a kind of tension, a kind of rawness and edginess that valves just smoothens out too much. To get close to real musical reproduction you need power, speed and accuracy of tone. Valves are too coloured.
You can get closer to a live performance with SS than vith Valves with the same amount of money spent. Of course if you spend even more money on the valves then I don't deny valves can come close to the real thing.
But having said that, a good valve pre driving a SS power amp can be quite an interesting prospect.
Not really Landy. a good tube amp driving sensitive speaker can b dynamic. a pair of 12w pc Eico HF12 monoblock playing LP can bang the floor like crazy when driving an alnico magnet JBL 15 incher.
wabun- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 423
Age : 46
Location : Ipoh
Registration date : 2009-03-02
Character sheet
Source(s): Mac mini - Bryston BDP - Calyx DAC 24/192 - Rega P8
Amplification: Jumpan Balance - ARC VT100Mk3 - Musical Fidelity FX
Speakers: JBL 4313B , Harbeth P3esr
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
Anyone here have any experience with "Dared" Valve Amps ?
cheers
cheers
wingman- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 855
Age : 53
Location : Am Here
Registration date : 2009-08-10
Character sheet
Source(s):
Amplification:
Speakers:
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
I would like to know also
arremie- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 533
Location : PJ
Registration date : 2009-02-09
Character sheet
Source(s): Oppo
Amplification: Parasound
Speakers: Klipsch
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
wabun wrote:Does an opinion from a girl matter???
Anyway, here goes. Yes, valves, nice but never enough driving power. A live musical performance has a kind of tension, a kind of rawness and edginess that valves just smoothens out too much. To get close to real musical reproduction you need power, speed and accuracy of tone. Valves are too coloured.
You can get closer to a live performance with SS than vith Valves with the same amount of money spent. Of course if you spend even more money on the valves then I don't deny valves can come close to the real thing.
But having said that, a good valve pre driving a SS power amp can be quite an interesting prospect.
I have to agree, even 4w with a over 100db/w speakers will do so much dynamics you will be startled when one hears it but unfortunately not many will get a chance to do so. Its not so common in our market here..
Not really Landy. a good tube amp driving sensitive speaker can b dynamic. a pair of 12w pc Eico HF12 monoblock playing LP can bang the floor like crazy when driving an alnico magnet JBL 15 incher.
dixchen- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 255
Age : 48
Location : Subang Jaya
Registration date : 2009-02-17
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
teleman.. LP idris muhammad you ade ke? fuhh.. soul jazz tu. i dgr kt 12au7 + rotel pwr amp kombo i munyik sbijik2.. slurrppp!!
azri- Frequent Contributor
- Number of posts : 1050
Age : 47
Location : bangi, selangor
Registration date : 2009-01-21
Re: Solid State or Tube preamp?
wabun wrote:Does an opinion from a girl matter???
Anyway, here goes. Yes, valves, nice but never enough driving power. A live musical performance has a kind of tension, a kind of rawness and edginess that valves just smoothens out too much. To get close to real musical reproduction you need power, speed and accuracy of tone. Valves are too coloured.
You can get closer to a live performance with SS than vith Valves with the same amount of money spent. Of course if you spend even more money on the valves then I don't deny valves can come close to the real thing.
But having said that, a good valve pre driving a SS power amp can be quite an interesting prospect.
Not really Landy. a good tube amp driving sensitive speaker can b dynamic. a pair of 12w pc Eico HF12 monoblock playing LP can bang the floor like crazy when driving an alnico magnet JBL 15 incher.
Well, there was one time I went to a friend's place for music practice and he had a pair of Tannoy Wesminsters tucked away in each corner of his livingroom. His Audionote Conquerers were out of commission because they blew a valve or something so in place of the Audionote was an inexpensive Dared VP16. 16watts maybe? I really don't know. But I must say I was impressed with the combination. Tonal accuracy aside, the combo was able to deliver realistic bass without bloom or boom and uncoloured midrange. Quite the opposite of my impression on valve gear and very modern sounding. Of course I wasn't truely satisfied with the performance but to rate it, i'd give it 4 out of 5 stars. So, coincidently this also answers the questions on Dared that some of you are asking.
Landy- Regular
- Number of posts : 60
Age : 47
Location : Penang
Registration date : 2010-03-09
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» Audio Reserch LS2B MKII Tube/Solid State Hybrid Line State Preamplifier (Used) SOLD
» Solid state preamp
» Bass boom after swapping from solid-state to tube power amp
» WTB: Headphone amp (Solid state or tube)
» tube vs solid state sequence
» Solid state preamp
» Bass boom after swapping from solid-state to tube power amp
» WTB: Headphone amp (Solid state or tube)
» tube vs solid state sequence
Hi-Fi 4 Sale - Malaysia / Singapore Audio Forum & Marketplace | www.hifi4sale.net :: Discussion Forum & Knowledge Base :: Equipment Discussions
Page 1 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum